Going to Beer Church should always be a thing. This place is unique, has a variety of items for drinks and food to choose from. I will say some of their food is a little out there, but in a good way. Its not your normal food list at a beer location. They have great merch options upstairs if you are in need of a shirt, mug, or many other items. Its definitely worth the stop in a rainy day and also great for a nice summer day up on the patio

The biscuits and gravy, Caesar salad, and pistachio gelato were very good. OJ was just ok and I prefer it without ice. Service was friendly. I had to go looking for silverware after the food arrived. This needs to be on the table no later than right after ordering.

We could resist going to church on a Friday. Stopping here was only because it was church. So glad we stopped by. Sat at the rooftop and enjoyed the best beer I've had. I had the MARGEAUX RITA and it was phenomenal. So good that I had more than a couple and I am left wanting MORE, MORE , MORE!! It's a margarita inspired Ale featuring agave nectar, sea salt, and fresh lime zest. We were able to find a perfect spot to sit at and enjoyed the view. Service was good. Will go back to church next summer.

You don't understand what you have here.. I am an italian from new York and only recently moved here. I have eaten pizza my entire life, at every famous pizza parlour in the city from bensonhurst to the bronx. The pizza here is 10/10 and is comparable to the best ones in nyc. My wife is asleep and im sneaking out of the house right now to get another pie. Five stars isnt enough.

We went on a lazy, Tuesday night mid August. It was practically emptied which was surprising cause it's usually packed during the summer evenings. Maybe Tuesdays just aren't. Waitress who served us was very nice and welcoming to cousin and nephew visiting from Mexico. Great beer and appetizer recommendations and the pizza was tasty. Look forward to coming back with wife to drink, repent, and repeat.

It was a super busy night but but the wait wasn't bad, and was well worth it. Super friendly service and the pizzas are delicious and shareable. The pork lollipop appetizer is delicious. Meat falls right off the bone and obviously the beer and drinks are on point. Great experience overall.

Interesting concept for a brewery being an old church. I'm sure there's a lot of history in this building. Just be warned with parking. It's extremely limited and awkward by the brewery. We had to park up the street in a public lot (half paved, half gravel). They serve food (e.g., pizza), gelato, wine, beer, etc. They have a wide selection of beers ranging from IPAs to ales to sours. Personally, I love sour beers. They have clever names for them all. It was my first time in New Buffalo. I had a good time.

Beer Church Brewing is located at the tail end of the main downtown New Buffalo strip. The Brewery has their own beers, specialty cocktails, a shot list, and more! Their food focus is neapolitan pizzas but they have other food as well. The inside is a renovated church but adjacent they have a two story outdoor patio. Our group sat at the bar as there was no wait; patio wait time when we arrived was 30-40 minutes. I tried their version of a cosmo which was good but a bit tart. Their tequila "boss" drink was also a but syrup tasting and sweeter than i would prefer. The round of green tea shots were made perfectly but the jesus juice shot was a strong miss of a suggestion. The bartenders were extremely nice and attentive to our group. They made us an espresso martini to try and it ended up being the best drink I tried while there!

An old church that was converted into a brewery! The whole place has stuck to the theme. They do small pours of their beer, so I tried 2 of their ipas. Both were tasty! They have beer, cocktails, mocktails, and shots that all are church themed. They also have woodfired pizza and Gelato. As it's in a popular touristy area, it does get crowded, and parking is tight. We parked across the street. Fun place, I would recommend!

After exploring today stopped in to for dinner. Located in a renovated church building. Brewing takes place outside. Indoor and patio seating. Started the meal off with a cup of the soup of the day. Today it was Cajun sausage and potato soup. I could have made a meal out of a full bowl of it, had great flavor and was full of meat/veggies. Picked the French dip off the feature menu for my entree. It said there were caramelized onions - they were sautéed, I removed them. The horseradish and dipping sauce made the sandwich so good, the bread was so good. My waitress was doing her first solo flight today, she did a great job. They have gelato available for dessert. Stop in and visit them if given the chance.